When Vulnerability Meets Vision: What I'm Learning from Opening My Classroom to Raw Entrepreneurial Truth

Sometimes the most powerful teaching moments come from stepping outside our comfort zones and inviting our students to witness authentic leadership in real time

I've been teaching entrepreneurship for the last few years, but I've never done anything quite like what happened in my Business 307 classroom this week. As I watched Charlynda Scales settle into the classroom, facing my students with a mix of determination and vulnerability I rarely see in academic settings, I knew we were about to embark on something extraordinary.

"I promise you, there's no question that you can ask me that I will not answer," Charlynda declared to my students. "Whether it is about being an entrepreneur, whether it's just about being a female in this industry, period. I will tell you everything. I'm actually known for being painfully transparent."

In that moment, I realized we weren't just conducting another guest speaker session. We were creating something entirely different: a living laboratory where theory meets the messy, beautiful reality of entrepreneurship.

The Fall 2025 Meredith College Venture Launch Course with Mentor, Charlynda Scales

Why I Chose This Path

My teaching philosophy has always centered on nurturing the inner knowing within each student. I believe every individual possesses a unique internal compass that guides them toward their passions and purpose. Traditional case studies, no matter how well-crafted, create a safe distance between students and the real emotional weight of entrepreneurial decisions.

When Charlynda approached me about using Mutt's Sauce as a live case study, complete with real financials, current challenges, and genuine stakes, I saw an opportunity to bridge that gap in a way I'd never attempted before.

The sauce itself carries profound meaning that resonates with everything I try to teach about authentic entrepreneurship. Created from a recipe passed down by her grandfather, a Korean and Vietnam War veteran whose call sign was "Mutt" due to his adaptability, the product represents far more than a condiment. Instead, it symbolizes the power of bringing people together, of creating connections across differences. These values align perfectly with what I hope my students learn about building meaningful businesses.

The Power of Transparent Storytelling

What struck me most about Charlynda's approach was her willingness to share the full story, including the difficult parts. She didn't shy away from discussing how appearing on Shark Tank without securing a deal, or how selling out on QVC while simultaneously going $20,000 into debt, shaped her understanding of entrepreneurship.

"On TV they're going to show you all the sexy side," she explained to my students. "They're going to tell you all the stuff that's glamorous, but we want them to be armed and you to be armed with all parts of the process, all parts of the life cycle to make better decisions."

This approach reflects exactly what I've been trying to accomplish in my own work with entrepreneurs. Rather than focusing solely on avoiding failure, I help them develop the resilience and wisdom to learn from every experience. Watching my students absorb these lessons from someone living them in real time was incredibly powerful.

Mentorship as a Mirror

One of the most compelling aspects of Charlynda's story is how mentorship transformed her trajectory. Through SCORE, she connected with John Soutar, who provided more than business advice. He helped her see how her grandfather's dream of creating generational wealth connected to her business purpose.

"The great thing about mentorship is they meet you where you are," Charlynda reflected. "A mentor will talk to you about your life because in the end your life is either what is making you want to start this business or your goal is personal."

As I listened to her describe this relationship, I realized she was articulating something I've experienced throughout my own entrepreneurial journey and try to embody in my teaching. The most transformative guidance comes from helping people connect their deepest values to their business decisions, rather than offering generic business advice.

The Innovation We're Creating Together

What Charlynda and I have designed goes beyond traditional case study methodology. Over the next 14 weeks, students will alternate between "Problem Immersion" sessions with her and "Strategic Analysis" sessions with me, building comprehensive strategic documents each week that culminate in real recommendations for her January 2026 relaunch.

This represents applied consulting with genuine consequences. My students know that their strategic recommendations could influence actual business decisions, which changes everything about their engagement and commitment to the work.

We're covering the full spectrum: financial modeling, distribution strategy, customer acquisition, operational scalability, brand positioning, all grounded in real data and real constraints. More importantly, we're exploring how personal values, purpose, and authentic leadership intersect with business strategy.

What I'm Learning as an Educator

This collaboration is teaching me as much as my students. Watching Charlynda navigate questions about work-life balance, I was struck by her response: "I don't subscribe to work-life balance. I don't think it exists... I subscribe to overcommunication, and I would rather overcommunicate with everyone who will be affected by my decisions."

This perspective challenges conventional wisdom in a way that feels both refreshing and pragmatic. These are exactly the kinds of authentic insights that come from lived experience rather than textbook theory.

The Ripple Effect I'm Hoping For

As both an educator and entrepreneur, I believe we have a responsibility to prepare future business leaders with wisdom alongside knowledge. The kind of wisdom that can only come from witnessing authentic leadership in action, complete with its vulnerabilities and uncertainties.

What we're creating here is a model that other institutions could replicate, emphasizing the spirit of radical transparency and authentic engagement. By combining real-world application with structured analysis, we're developing entrepreneurs who understand that success comes from asking better questions and remaining true to their values while adapting to challenges, rather than having all the answers from the start.

This experience has reinforced something I've long believed: the most powerful learning happens when we step outside our comfort zones and invite others to do the same. Charlynda's willingness to be vulnerable with my students creates space for them to be vulnerable too, with their own ideas, fears, and aspirations.

I'm watching students who typically focus on grades and assignments begin to ask deeper questions about what kind of entrepreneurs they want to become. They're examining their own values and how those might shape their future ventures, moving beyond simply analyzing business models.

What’s Next?

As we continue this journey together over the semester, I'm excited to see how both Charlynda's business strategy and my students' understanding of entrepreneurship evolve. We're all learning in real time, and that shared vulnerability creates an energy that traditional classroom structures simply can't replicate.

The story of Mutt's Sauce continues to unfold, and the story of how we're revolutionizing entrepreneurship education through radical transparency and authentic mentorship is something I'm proud to be documenting and sharing with the broader entrepreneurial education community.

Sometimes the best teaching moments come from admitting we don't have all the answers and inviting our students to help us figure things out together. In a world that often rewards certainty over curiosity, there's something beautifully subversive about building a classroom around questions rather than answers.

This is part of our ongoing series documenting innovative approaches to entrepreneurship education. If you're an educator interested in similar collaborative models, or an entrepreneur willing to share your journey authentically with students, I'd love to connect.

_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

FAQ

What is innovative entrepreneurship education?

Innovative entrepreneurship education moves beyond traditional case studies to engage students with real businesses facing current challenges. This approach combines theoretical frameworks with live problem-solving, allowing students to work directly with founders on actual business strategies and experiential, hands-on learning. At Meredith College, Professor Molly McKinley has pioneered this method by partnering with veteran entrepreneur Charlynda Scales to use her company, Mutt's Sauce, as a living laboratory for strategic business development.

How does live case study methodology work in business education?

Live case study methodology involves students working directly with active entrepreneurs to solve real business challenges in real-time. Unlike traditional case studies that analyze historical business decisions, this approach allows students to develop strategies that could actually be implemented. Students alternate between "Problem Immersion" sessions with the entrepreneur and "Strategic Analysis" sessions with their professor, building comprehensive strategic documents throughout the semester that culminate in actionable business recommendations.

What makes Charlynda Scales' approach to mentorship unique?

Charlynda Scales brings radical transparency to entrepreneurship education, sharing both successes and failures with equal authenticity. As a decorated Air Force officer with over 15 years of cross-sector leadership experience, she provides students with unfiltered insights into the realities of building a business. Her approach includes sharing financial details, discussing strategic mistakes, and revealing the emotional journey of entrepreneurship, which gives students a complete picture of what building a company actually entails.

Why is authentic entrepreneurship education important for business students?

Authentic entrepreneurship education prepares students for the real challenges they'll face as business leaders by exposing them to genuine vulnerabilities and uncertainties. Traditional business education often sanitizes the entrepreneurial experience, focusing on success stories without adequate attention to the learning that comes from setbacks. When students witness authentic leadership in action, including the decision-making process during difficult times, they develop resilience and wisdom alongside technical business skills.

How does transparent leadership benefit entrepreneurship students?

Transparent leadership in educational settings allows students to see the full spectrum of entrepreneurial decision-making, including the personal values and emotional considerations that influence business strategy. When entrepreneurs like Charlynda Scales share their complete journey, including financial struggles, strategic pivots, and personal growth, students learn that successful leadership isn't about having all the answers but about remaining authentic while adapting to challenges.

How do real-world business partnerships enhance academic learning?

Real-world business partnerships in academic settings provide students with immediate application opportunities for theoretical concepts while giving entrepreneurs access to fresh perspectives and strategic analysis. These collaborations create mutual value: students gain practical experience with genuine stakes, while business owners receive comprehensive strategic recommendations from multiple analytical perspectives. The partnership between Professor McKinley and Charlynda Scales demonstrates how academic rigor can be combined with entrepreneurial authenticity to create powerful learning experiences.

What role does mentorship play in successful entrepreneurship education?

Mentorship in entrepreneurship education goes beyond providing business advice to include personal guidance that helps students connect their values to their business goals. Effective mentorship, as demonstrated in Charlynda Scales' experience with her SCORE mentor John Soutar, involves meeting entrepreneurs where they are personally and helping them see how their life experiences and goals connect to their business objectives. This holistic approach to mentorship is now being integrated into formal educational settings to provide students with more comprehensive preparation for entrepreneurial leadership.

How does Meredith College's entrepreneurship program differ from traditional business education?

Meredith College's entrepreneurship program, led by Professor Molly McKinley, emphasizes nurturing students' internal compass and authentic leadership development rather than just teaching business techniques. The program uses innovative methodologies like live case studies, direct entrepreneur partnerships, and radical transparency to prepare students for the emotional and strategic challenges of building businesses. This approach recognizes that successful entrepreneurship requires both technical skills and personal authenticity.

What is the significance of Mutt's Sauce as an educational case study?

Mutt's Sauce serves as an ideal educational case study because it combines authentic personal meaning with genuine business challenges. Founded by Charlynda Scales to honor her grandfather's legacy, the company represents the intersection of purpose and profit that characterizes many meaningful entrepreneurial ventures. The business has experienced both successes (QVC sales, Shark Tank appearance) and challenges (debt, operational difficulties), providing students with a complete picture of the entrepreneurial journey and multiple strategic opportunities to explore.

How can educators implement similar innovative teaching methods?

Educators interested in implementing similar innovative teaching methods should focus on building authentic partnerships with entrepreneurs willing to share their complete business journey, including challenges and failures. The key elements include structured problem-solving frameworks, alternating immersion and analysis sessions, real stakes for student recommendations, and emphasis on personal authenticity alongside business strategy. Successful implementation requires finding entrepreneur partners who value education and are committed to transparency in sharing their experiences with students.